RICHMOND, December 13, 1861.
Hon. J. P. BENJAMIN,
Secretary of War:
SIR: I arrived at, Knoxville about the 1st day of December,
assumed command, and established my headquarters there. At that time Mr. W. G.
Brownlow was absent from Knoxville, where he resides. Very soon some friend or
friends of his approached me on the subject of his return to Knoxville, and I
had several interviews with the son of Mr. Brownlow, who was interceding and
acting for his father in the premises. During several days Mr. Brownlow's son
was very importunate in calling upon me and making solicitations in behalf of
his father of some sort or another. In the beginning, the letter of Mr.
Brownlow to General Carroll, dated November 22, and received about the time of
my arrival, was handed to me and discussed between myself and the son of Mr.
Brownlow. In this letter Mr. Brownlow stated that he was willing and ready at
any time to stand a trial upon any points before any civil tribunal, but sought
protection from troops and armed men on a return to Knoxville, denying at the
same time having had any connection with arming men or with armed bodies of men
or with bridge-burners or bridge-burning. General Carroll also handed to me his
reply to this letter.
In the several interviews between the son of Mr. Brownlow
and one or more of his friends and myself Mr. Brownlow's innocence of any
treasonable conduct was vouched as the basis of any disposition to be made
towards him, and I stated to Mr. Brownlow's son, who was acting for his father,
that if he came to Knoxville he must submit to the civil authorities.
Finally, about the 4th or 5th of December, I think, Mr.
Baxter, a friend of Mr. Brownlow, together with his son, called upon me, and
Mr. Baxter delivered to me an open letter from yourself, brought by him, dated
November 20, and referring to Mr. Brownlow's departure beyond our lines.
Thereupon, and on the solicitations made to me in behalf of Mr. Brownlow, I
directed my assistant adjutant-general to inform Mr. Brownlow in writing that
if he would come to Knoxville within a given time I would give him a passport
and send him with an escort beyond our lines. I designed this escort to convey
him directly through our lines, so that he could see nothing of our forces and
fortifications. At the given time Mr. Brownlow came, and I made arrangements
with him as to the time and manner of his departure, which were satisfactory to
him. I designed sending him off the next day, but he desired to stay over a
day, and on that day, before his departure, was arrested with a warrant by the
civil authorities on a charge of treason.
Mr. Brownlow addressed a note to me, stating his arrest, and
that he had come home upon my invitation, and claimed to be under my
protection. As I had stated explicitly to Mr. Brownlow's son, who acted for his
father, and who went after and did conduct his father into town, that if he
came he must submit to the civil authorities, and as his innocence of any
treasonable conduct was considered in the arrangements for him, I directed one
of my aides to reply to his note to the effect that, in view of all the facts,
I could not interfere with the civil authorities so as to protect him from an
investigation by them of charges made in their tribunals against him, which I
clearly understood from himself and his friends he would not seek to avoid.
Of course, if the civil authorities release Mr. Brownlow, I
shall proceed at once to give him a passport and send him with an escort beyond
our lines.
I remain, very respectfully, yours, &c,
G. B. CRITTENDEN,
Major-General, C. S. Army.
SOURCE: The War of the Rebellion: A
Compilation of the Official Records of the Union and Confederate Armies,
Series I, Volume 7 (Serial No. 7), p. 763-4