Saturday, November 21, 2026

Congressman Albert G. Brown’s Speech On The Proposition to Establish A General Committee on Claims, December 20, 1852

SPEECH IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, DECEMBER 20, 1852, ON THE PROPOSITION TO ESTABLISH A GENERAL COMMITTEE ON CLAIMS.

MR. BROWN. I ask the unanimous consent of the House to introduce the resolution which I proposed on Friday last.

There being no objection, the resolution was read, as follows:

"Resolved, That the following be added to the rules of the House of Representatives:

 

"There shall be appointed a standing committee of the House of Representatives, to consist of fifteen members, to be called The General Committee on Claims, whose duty it shall be to report a bill at each session of Congress making appropriations for the payment of private claimants. It shall be the duty of the other committees of this House, when they have prepared a written report in favor of any claim, to transmit their report, together with the evidence on which it is based, to said General Committee on Claims; and if said committee, after due examination, shall concur in said report, they shall insert an item for the payment of said claim in the bill for the payment of private claimants, and thereupon submit to the House the report and evidence aforesaid, to be printed or otherwise disposed of, as the House may direct. And upon the demand of a single member, a separate vote shall be had on any section of said bill designated by him, notwithstanding the previous question may have been moved and seconded."

Mr. BROWN said: Mr. Speaker, it is conceded that the present mode of treating private claims amounts to a denial of justice, and ought to be changed.

For several years a proposition was urged upon Congress to establish a board of claims. For a time I was strongly inclined to sustain this proposition; but reflection satisfied me that, to make it efficient, it would be dangerous, and possibly a violation of the Constitution.

A board of claims would investigate; but it is not investigation that we want. We want action—final action. Our present committees investigate claims and report bills, but we do not pass those bills. Bills to which there is no reasonable objection remain for years upon the calendar without action. The claimant grows weary and sick with hopes deferred, but Congress will not act. The bills are not passed, and just claims are not paid. This ought not to be. The creditors of the government have as much right to their pay as the creditors of private persons.

These tedious and sickening delays ought to be remedied. It cannot be safely done, in my judgment, by the appointment of a board of claims. It is the least objection (and yet it is an objection) to the appointment of such a board that it will increase Executive patronage, already grown quite too large.

If such a board is created, it will, as I have said, give us investigation; but what then? "No money shall be drawn from the treasury but in consequence of appropriations made by law," says the Constitution. Will you appropriate an aggregate sum, and allow the board to check it from the treasury as they may see fit, and apply it to the payment of claims? To do this, you must delegate to the board a power over the public funds which belongs exclusively to Congress, and which I very much question your right to transfer to another. The right to appropriate presupposes the existence of an object to which the appropriation may rightfully be made. The Constitution, in my judgment, contemplates that Congress shall decide as to the merits of the object to which the money is to be applied before making the appropriation. To make the appropriation first, and then leave others to decide as to the merits of the object to which it may be applied, is to shrink from the performance of one-half, and that to the treasury the most important half of your duty.

Could you appropriate $10,000,000 for the support of the army, and leave to the Secretary of War, or even to the President and cabinet, the privilege of applying it as he or they should see fit? Possibly you may have the power. But its exercise would dissatisfy the country, and strain, if it did not break the Constitution. It would, to say the least, be a very loose control over the public funds. It would be a still more loose control of them to appropriate $1,000,000 or $500,000, or a greater or less sum, and leave a board of commissioners to parcel it out among private claimants as the board should adjudge right. To do such an act would be to invite constant repetitions of the disgraceful Gardiner frauds. I am very confident Congress will commit no such folly.

What then shall we do? After the board has investigated and reported favorably on claims, shall we pass bills to pay them? This brings us just to the point where we now are; for I repeat, it is action, and not investigation, that we want—action, action. The passage of bills, that is what we want. And why is it that we do not act? why is it that we do not pass bills? It is, sir, because we have not confidence, we have not full confidence in the investigations of our committees. And shall we have more confidence, I pray you, in a board of claims? Will we distrust our own committees, and rely with confidence on the board of claims? I think not. When we are called to act, when we are called to pass bills, to make appropriations, we shall have the same difficulty that we now have. Some doubting Thomas will ejaculate those cabalistic words, "I object!" and in a twinkling the bill fades from our view, and the poor claimant is turned away in sorrow.

I want something practical; something that will give the claimants justice; something that will protect the treasury against fraud; keep the people's money under the control of the people's representatives, and at the same time relieve the Speaker's table from that accumulated and accumulating mass of private business under which it has literally groaned for five-and-twenty years.

The rule which I propose will do this. I have reflected on it maturely, and my confidence is entire that it will be efficient for all the purposes I have indicated.

What does it propose? First, a committee of fifteen, to be styled the General Committee on Claims; and why a committee of fifteen? I have, in my own judgment, fixed a large number, because the functions of the committee will be onerous, varied, and perplexing. No small committee could well discharge the duties which I propose to devolve on this general committee.

What will be the duties of this committee? To exercise a supervisory jurisdiction, in the first place, over all the reports from the other committees touching private claims. To stand as a kind of appellate court, having no original jurisdiction, but authorized and required to review the reports of other committees, and only to ask the action of Congress in case they approve such reports; and, in the second place, to report a bill for the payment of private claimants, the items of which shall in all cases be founded on the approved reports of other committees.

Allow me to illustrate, by supposed cases, the practical workings of this rule, if it shall be adopted. A claim is referred to the Committee on the Post Office and Post Roads; another to the Committee on Public Lands, and another to the Committee on Claims. Each of these committees makes a favorable report. These reports, and the evidence to sustain them, they send to the General Committee on Claims. That committee, after due investigation, approve each one of the reports, and thereupon they insert a separate item in the bill for the payment of private claimants to cover each claim, and then lay the report and evidence before the House to be printed, if the House shall so direct. And so of every other claim. It will be seen that each particular item will be sustained by a separate report, and that report will be supported by the concurrent judgment of two separate committees. The bill thus reported must of necessity go to the Committee of the Whole House, and being here considered, item by item, every member of Congress will have ample opportunity for the fullest and fairest investigation. When the bill is at last reported to the House for final action, each particular item will have passed the ordeal of the three separate committees: First, the present committee of nine; next, the proposed committee of fifteen; and lastly, the Committee of the Whole House. Having thus run the gauntlet, it seems to me no reasonable man could object to a vote by yeas and nays, as to whether the bill should become a law. The advantages which I anticipate are-first, thorough investigation, and therefore entire security to the government; and secondly, certain action, and consequently a hope of justice to claimants.

If Congress can be induced to act at all, it will generally act justly. Congress often does not act because of the anxiety of each member to get his own business forward. In the general scramble for precedence the avenues of legislation are choked up, private bills are neglected, and the rights of private parties disregarded. I desire to change this state of things; put all on the same footing, and this scramble will cease. Under the rule which I propose, we shall have but one bill instead of many hundred bills. The struggle which is constantly going on here for precedence will cease, because all these rival bills will be merged into one bill. This bill will never fail of being considered and passed. It only remains to determine whether the checks and guards which the rule imposes will be sufficient to protect the treasury. In the first place, you have the examination of the committees as at present organized; their duties, so far as investigation is concerned, remain unchanged. In the second place, we have the proposed committee of fifteen, with no original jurisdiction, but sitting only as a revisory court; it is their duty to weigh the evidence and determine whether it sustains the report; and thirdly, we have the Committee of the Whole House. All these committees must pass affirmatively upon each section of the bill separately, before it is laid before the House, and in the House the rule guaranties to every member the right to demand a separate vote upon any section of the bill to which he may object. Now, it does seem to me that if a bill has passed three committees of this House section by section, and has then run the hazard of a separate vote by sections in the House, no reasonable man ought to object to its becoming a law.

If the House does not choose to adopt this rule, I hope at least we shall do something to relieve private claimants from the crushing and overpowering influence of a single member when pronouncing those potential words, "I object!" "I object!" How often the heedless or captious use of these words has sent honest claimants in sadness and in sorrow from this Hall! Let us snatch from them this unnatural power and restore them to their original modest position in our political vocabulary, and we shall have taken one step at least towards a salutary reform.

SOURCE: M. W. Cluskey, Editor, Speeches, Messages, and Other Writings of the Hon. Albert G. Brown, A Senator in Congress from the State of Mississippi, pp. 318-21

Friday, November 20, 2026

Diary of Lucy Larcom, January 19, 1862

How hard it is to know anything of history, to learn enough to feel at all competent to teach! I said I would look through Gibbon, but I had hardly reached the times of Julian, before my class must be hurrying beyond Charlemagne, and I must turn to French histories to help them along. Then, between de Bonnechose and Sir James Stephen, with the various writers on the Middle Ages, which must be consulted for the history of the feudal system, free cities, and the Papacy, comes in the remembrance of my Bible class in the early history of the church, and I must give some hours to Neander! Meanwhile, another class is reading Shakespeare, and I want them to be somewhat critical, and must therefore read, myself; while yet another class in Metaphysics are beginning the history of philosophy, and I want them to know something about Plato, and the Alexandrian schools, and knowing very little myself I must find out something first. So I bring to my room the volumes containing the "Timæus" and the "Republic;" but in the midst of it, I remember that there are some compositions to be corrected, that I may be ready for the new ones Monday morning. This is pretty much where Saturday night finds me, and so the weeks go on, this winter. I am glad to be busy, but I dislike to be superficial. Now, if I could teach only history, I should feel as though I might hope to do something. (Girls will be ill-educated, until their teachers are allowed the time and thought which teachers of men are expected to take.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, pp. 118-9

Diary of Lucy Larcom, January 22, 1862

I am trying to get an idea which is rolling in grand chaos through my mind into shape for a composition theme for my first class this afternoon. It is the power of the soul in moulding form — from the great Soul of the universe, down to lower natures, down to animal and vegetable life. Plato's doctrine of ideas is the only starting point I can think of; some thoughts of Swedenborg's will help; then Lavater and the Physiologists and Psychologists. But I want them to use it practically; to take particular persons, features, shape, gait, manner, voice, life; and then observe closely how beauty develops itself in flowers, leaves, pebbles, into infinite variety, yet according to invariable laws. It is a hard thing to bring such subjects into shape which young girls can grasp; yet they are the best things for opening the mind upon a broad horizon.

For a review of the week I must think of Plato; the "Republic," and "Timæus," and "Critias," I have succeeded in looking through; I have heard my "Mental" class read some of the rest. In the "Republic," I remember it is decided that youths should be taught in music, — no enfeebling melodies, but those which strengthen and build up the soul in all that is vast and true. Plato's idea of music comprehends more than we read in the word; and I see how it is that an education should be musical, the spiritual fabric rising like the walls of Troy to the Orphean strains of noble thoughts and impulses.

I remember, too, that he would forbid some of the stories of the Gods to be told to children; those which should needlessly alarm them, or weaken their reverence. In that corrupt and yet beautiful system, it was necessary indeed; the same idea might be not injuriously carried out in a system of Christian education. In the Hebrew Scriptures there is much that puzzles the maturest minds, sincere and earnest in their search for truth; yet these narratives are the first knowledge that children often have of the Bible. I would have them learn only the New Testament, until they have learned something of the real nature of the world they are ushered into. When they study other history, they will be better able to understand this; and the history of the Jews is, it seems to me, a wonderful part of the world's record, so connected with that of other nations as to make them plainer, revealing the handwriting of an Almighty Providence everywhere.

I would not have the child begin life with the terror which hung over my childhood: told that I was a sinner before I knew what sin meant, and fearful pictures of eternal punishment which awaited all sinners at death haunting my dreams, so that I was afraid to sleep, and more afraid to die. I know they say (a good man has just said it to me) that there is less vigor of mind and character because these things are less taught as a part of religion than formerly; yet I am sure that blind — fear cannot invigorate, — it must degrade. I believe that I went far down from my earliest ideals of life after hearing these things; and it was a long straying amid shadowy half-truths, and glooms of doubt, and stagnations of indifference, before I came back to the first thought of my childhood. No: let a child's life be beautiful as God meant it to be, by keeping it near Him, by showing to its simplicity the things which are lovely, and true, and pure, and of good report. The knowledge of evil comes rapidly enough, in the petty experiences of life; but a child will soon love evil and grow old in it, if driven away from the divine light of love; if not allowed to think of God chiefly as a friend. And just here is where Christ speaks to the hearts of little children; they know Him as soon as He is permitted to speak, and are known of Him.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, p. 119-21

Diary of Lucy Larcom, January 29, 1862

I believe that letter-writing is more of a reality to me now than conversation; short though my notes are, I can speak thus to those who need me, and whom I need.

Repose of character, and the power of forgetting, are great compensations for a tried, hurried, and worried life. And there is, in all but the most unusual lives, something like this, which enables people to laugh at care, and triumph over grief; though it is never perfectly done, except by a thorough trust in the goodness of God, — a faith in the watching love.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, pp. 121-2

Diary of Lucy Larcom, February 5, 1862

I did have the sleigh-ride with my young friends, as I expected, and a merry one it was.

We just whirled through Attleboro, and back again. All I remember of the ride is the icicles that hung on the orchard trees and, just at sunset, the tints that fell on a slope of unstained snow. They were the softest, coolest shades of blue and violet, with here and there a suggestion of rose or crimson, a perfectly magical combination of shadow colors, only half escaped from their white light-prison of the snow. It was a hint of the beauty of an Alpine or a Polar landscape, such as travelers tell about. The young moon followed one queenly star down the west, as we returned, with a song of "Glory Hallelujah," and "Homeward Bound."

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, p. 122

Diary of Lucy Larcom, February 6, 1862

The clear blue of this morning's sky has melted into a mass of snowy clouds, and now earth and sky are of the same hue, — white — white, the purest crystalline snow is on the ground, and more is coming. The violet hues in the north at sunrise and sunset are very beautiful.

I am glad I took my walk in the woods this morning while the sky was bright; there are fine tints there always on the trees, various browns of withered oaks and beech-leaves, still persistent, and leaning against the stout pine trunks, that hold up their constant green to the sky. Two trees I noticed for the first time, a pine and a maple, which have grown up with their trunks in close union, almost one from infancy. One keeps his dark green mantle on, the other has lost her light summer robe, but is covered all over with the softest clinging lichens, that contrast their pale green tints with the white-gray bark in a charming way. When snow falls on these lichen-draped boughs, the softness of the white above and the white below is wonderful. I think Neck-woods is a grand studio; when weary of my own white walls I can always find refreshment there.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, pp. 122-3

Diary of Lucy Larcom, February 7, 1862

The news of Sarah Paine's death overwhelms me, — so young, so sensitive, so genial and accomplished; she seemed made to enter deeply into the reality and beauty of an earthly life. No pupil of mine has ever yet come near me in so many ways to sympathize and gladden as she. Only a few weeks since, we walked together in the woods, so full of life and hope she was; and now, in a moment, — but why this sorrow, since she is but suddenly called home to deeper love and purer life?

How every failure of tenderness and perfect appreciation on my part comes back to pain me now! Why have I not written to her? Why have I waited for her to write to me? Oh, what is worse than to fail of loving truly?

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, p. 123

Diary of Lucy Larcom, February 13, 1862

I had decided to go to her funeral, and went to Boston for the purpose, but a sleepless night left me too wretched to undertake the journey, and I spent the days in Boston feeling too miserable to come back here, or to stay there. How much of my life is gone with this friend! gone? no; translated, lifted up with her to her new estate! Yet much is gone from the world: the beauty of the walks about here, of the studies we have loved and pursued together, — I hardly knew how much this young life had woven itself into mine. And it was the deeper, spiritual sympathies fusing all love into one deep harmony of life, it was the love of the all-loving One that brought us closest together; and that makes “was” the wrong word to use, in speaking of her; she is my friend still, and the light of her new life will enter into mine.

One after another, those who have come nearest to me to love, to sympathize, to guide, pass on into purer air, and make me feel that my life is not here; my home is with the beloved.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, pp. 123-4

Diary of Lucy Larcom, February 17, 1862

There is news to-day of great victories in progress for us. Fort Donelson is surrounded; there has been a deadly fight, and our flag waves upon the outer fortifications. It is said that the rebels must yield, as all approaches are cut off, but it is the struggle of desperation with them, as this is the key to the whole Southwest. There are victories in Missouri and in North Carolina also; more prisoners taken than our generals know what to do with; but all this is purchased at such a price of blood!

In the days I stayed in Boston last week I visited two galleries of paintings, ancient and modern. The old paintings are chiefly curious, not beautiful, often very coarse in conception. I should like to see something really great by the "old masters;" but I suppose such things are only to be seen in Europe.

I believe I love landscape more than figures, unless these latter are touched by a master's hand. To be commonplace in dealing with nature does not seem quite so bad as in dealing with human beings.

I heard Ralph Waldo Emerson speak too. “Civilization" was his subject; nobly treated, except that the part of Hamlet was left out of Hamlet. What is civilization without Christianity? There was a kind of religion in what he said; an acknowledging of all those elements which are the result of Christianity; indeed, Emerson's life and character are such as Christianity would shape. He only refuses to call his inspiration by its right name. The source of all great and good thought is in Christ; so I could listen to the Sage of Concord, and recognize the voice of the Master he will not own in words.

Hitch your wagon to a star!" was his way of telling his hearers to live nobly, according to the high principles which are at the heart of all life. The easiest way to live, he said, was to follow the order of the Universe. So it is. "The stars in their courses fought against Sisera;" but it was because Sisera would go the opposite way to the stars. This is the secret of our struggle, and of our victory that will be. We have entangled ourselves with wrong, have gone contrary to the Divine Order; now, if we come out plainly and strongly on the right side, we triumph; for Right cannot fail. This war will make a nation of great and true souls; if we fight for freedom. And what else is worth the conflict, the loss of life? The Union, a Country — a home? Yes, if these may be preserved in honor and humanity, not otherwise. Better be parceled out among the nations than keep the stigma of inhumanity upon our great domain. Freedom for slavery is no freedom to a noble soul.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, pp. 124-6

Diary of Lucy Larcom, February 21, 1862

I have often wondered what is the meaning of these dim forebodings, that, without any apparent cause, will sometimes make us so uneasy. The air is bright, cold, and clear; everything without says, “Rejoice and be strong!" everything within is darkened by vague, unaccountable flutterings of anticipated ill. No sorrow can come to me which will not involve some greater grief of other hearts, so I dread the more what I have to dread. I think I cannot say of anything that is dear to me, that it is all my own; can any one? Mothers, lovers, husbands, wives these have exclusive joys, and exclusive losses to risk. I can lose much, for I love much; yet there is nothing on earth that I can feel myself holding firmly as mine. So I seek to live in others' joy and sorrow. A life large and deep in its love, is the privilege of those placed as I am; it must be either that, or quite unloving, shut up in its own small case of selfishness. "When Thou shalt enlarge my heart," this large feeling of rest will be found.

I have plans floating in my mind for the education of my nieces. I could not afford to have them here without a salary much increased.

I think I could conduct their education myself, in some small school, better than here, more according to my own ideas; whether that is really better or not, only the results would show. But some of their studies I know I could make more valuable to them than those to whom they might be trusted. Then I have an idea of moral, religious, and mental development going on at the same time, which I do not often see carried out; perhaps I should not do it, but I should like to try. Having no children of my own I feel a responsibility for those who are nearest me. How much of an effort one should make for such a purpose as this, I do not know. So far, I have been evidently led into the way I ought to take; may it be so still!

It was a new sight to me, to see a long line of cavalry, extending far out of sight down the street, a forest of bayonets at first, and then an army of horses. It was our National Guard; and it looked like a strong defense, that bristling line of bayonets; but it made me very sad to think that men must leave home, and peaceful occupations, and moral influences, to punish rebellious brethren, and keep them in awe. War, as a business, is one that I cannot learn to believe in, although I must realize it as a necessity.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, pp. 126-8

Diary of Lucy Larcom, February 26, 1862

For any of us to comprehend thoroughly Kant, Fichte, Schelling, Hegel —  to say nothing of the plainer sensualistic systems in the little time we can give to the study, is quite out of the question. And yet it does these young girls good to know that there is a region of thought above and beyond their daily track, and if they should ever have time, they may enjoy exploring it. Besides, the habit of looking upon life in a large way comes through philosophy Christianized. The right use of our faculties in a reverent search for truth is certainly worth much thought and painstaking from man or woman.

To live a child-like, religious life in all things is what I would do; simply receiving light and life from the love revealed within, and so, as a child, claiming the inheritance of the world without, which was created by the same Love for loving souls; but the earthly cleaves to me; I lose simplicity of soul in the world's windings.

Yet I own but one Life, one Lord and Redeemer; in Him only shall I find for myself the simplicity of the child and the wisdom of the Seraph. In Him all things are mine. Beautiful ideals may deceive one. Because we see and can talk about noble things, does it follow that we can live them? I fear not always.

SOURCE: Daniel Dulany Addison, Lucy Larcom: Life, Letters, and Diary, p. 128

Diary of Elvira J. Powers, Thursday Evening, May 19, 1864

My friend is somewhat better, but is very restless, and sleeps but little. She has been moved to a large, pleasant room in the third story where the air is purer, but the two large windows which open upon the front street and which must be open all the time to furnish air for the invalid, admit the continual tramp, tramp, tramp of the soldiers or horses, and the rumble of wheels through the long day and night. Her physician and friends think the only chance for her life is to obtain the pure air of the North and the quiet of home. It is in contemplation to send her as soon as it is considered safe for her to undertake the journey by water.

Have just returned from the Capitol, where I enjoyed the novelty of listening to the lecture in the Hall of Representatives, and by moonlight, which is described without date in Chapter Third. Rev. Drs. Thompson, of New York City, and Buddington, of Brooklyn, have just returned from the front to-day, and were witnesses of the battle near Dalton and Resaca.

Found a telegram from the brother of my patient upon my return. My last letter will reach him in reply

SOURCE: Elvira J. Powers, Hospital Pencillings: Being a Diary While in Jefferson General Hospital, Jeffersonville, Ind., and Others at Nashville, Tennessee, as Matron and Visitor, pp. 79