Am just from Der Freischiitz with Ellie and Mrs. Georgey
Peters. The lovely phrases of the finale are not quite out of my ears yet. Formes
was Caspar; Stigelli, Max; and Fabbri the heroine. The best performance of the
opera I have seen. The Fabbri misconceived her part, took everything too slow
and spoiled the glorious allegro of the “Wie nachte mir der schlummer” scene by
breaking it up into little bits of light and shadow instead of giving us the
sustained rush of joyous melody which Weber meant it to be, and which she could
have made it if she tried. But in that scene, perhaps, and in Caspar’s drinking
song certainly, Weber overrated the capacities of voice, energy, and expression.
No mortal ever existed who could render them as they should be rendered and do
full justice to their intensity. . . .
No change in the aspect of political matters. Samuel J.
Tilden has come out with a letter (anti-Republican) that shows far more depth
and ability; than I’ve given him credit for. He has passed for a commonplace,
clever, political wire-puller, but he deals with this great question in a
statesman-like way. Southern papers and stump orators continue in a blatant
way. Fortunately a deal of mischievous gas is liberated and made audible which
might be energetic for evil were it pent up. . . .
Republicans refuse to believe secession possible (in which I
think they are wrong), and maintain that were it accomplished, it would do us
no lasting mischief. I am sure it would do fatal mischief to one section or another
and great mischief to both. Amputation weakens the body, and the amputated limb
decomposes and perishes. Is our vital center North or South? Which is Body and
which is Member? We may have to settle that question by experiment. We are not
a polypoid organism that can be converted into two organisms by mere bisection.
China is a specimen of that type, but we claim higher rank. Bisection is disaster
and degradation, but if the only alternative is everlasting submission to the
South, it must come soon, and why should it not come now? What is gained by
postponing it four years longer? I feel Republican tonight.
SOURCE: Allan Nevins and Milton Halset Thomas,
Editors, Diary of George Templeton Strong, Vol. 3, p. 56