- Nicholas Davis
- Frank Doyle
- Charles Hasker (survived)
- John Kelly
- Lt. John A. Payne (survived)
- Absolum Williams
- William Robinson (survived)
2nd Crew:
- Horace Hunley (Captain)
- Robert Brockbank
- Joseph Patterson
- Thomas W. Park
- Charles McHugh
- Henry Baird
- John Marshall
- Charles L. Sprague
3rd Crew:
- Lieutenant George E. Dixon
- Frank Collins
- Joseph F. Ridgaway
- James A. Wicks
- Arnold Becker
- Corporal Johan Frederik Carlsen
- C. Lumpkin
- Augustus Miller
